| |

return
to list of language debates
 Links in this essay will take you to information about the usage experts and their work. Numbers in parentheses are page references.
To read about this topic in The Bedford
Handbook, see section
24g. |
|
In which sentence does the teacher dislike the child?
The teacher dislikes the child whispering to his
classmate.
The teacher dislikes the child’s whispering to his
classmate.
If you chose the first sentence, you are right. This
sentence emphasizes the child, whereas the other one
stresses the whispering. In the second sentence, the
possessive form child’s signals that
whispering is a gerund, a verb form used as a
noun. The writer of this sentence is following a
traditional grammar rule: For subjects of gerunds, use
possessive nouns or pronouns.
Usage experts
disagree on the extent to which writers should adhere to
this rule. Long ago, H. W. Fowler, who supported the
rule, admitted that it was “on the retreat” (610).
The American Heritage Book of English Usage
claims that the rule has been broken by “respected
writers for 300 years” and that the result “is perfectly
idiomatic” (17). The same book’s usage panel supports
the rule in simple sentences but tends to allow
exceptions in complex constructions.
Nearly everyone
agrees that exceptions must be allowed. As Patricia
O’Conner says, this rule (like many others) is worth
following “except when it leads you off a cliff” (47).
Consider O’Conner’s example:
Basil objects to men and women kissing in
public.
The possessive
men’s and women’s sounds awkward, and since there
is no possible confusion about the writer’s meaning,
it’s best to allow an exception to the rule. But the
rule still stands, says O’Conner, and in simpler
constructions we should follow it: Basil objects to
our [not us] kissing in
public.
When using the
possessive is awkward, you can sometimes recast the
sentence: Basil doesn’t like to see men and women
kissing in public. Here the emphasis is on the men
and women, and kissing in public is a participial
phrase modifying men and women. Because the
-ing phrase does not function as a gerund, the
possessive is not required.
Conclusion: Use a
possessive noun or pronoun as the subject of a gerund
unless doing so results in an awkward sentence. Then
either recast the sentence or disregard the rule. When
you choose to disregard the rule, though, make sure your
meaning is clear.
|